Helix Charter High School20002001200220032004captured Jan 10, 2004

Evaluating Web Pages

The World Wide Web has a host of information to choose from, and since almost anyone can create a site, you should be wary of any information you find online. Learning to select from the various site offerings can be quite confusing, yet their are some clues you can look for to help you critically select the information you use. Below you will find a list of clues you should look for and deduce whether you can trust the information provided. Pretend you are Sherlock Holmes and unravel the mystery of which sites you can trust, and which sites have their own motives. Moriarty is lurking out there and waiting for you to fall into his trap.

My Clues

Become a Web Site Sleuth

Questions

You should ask yourself the following questions about these particular clues that you may discover in your web site searching for the perfect information.

1. URL - The website's address can offer some clue to the author and publishing body?

Check the domain, it will give you a hint as to where it comes from. Is it educational (.edu), nonprofit (.org), commerical (.com), governmental (.gov), etc.

www.helixcharter.net

2. Author - Who is the author, his or her credentials, position, authority on the subject written, education, political views?

You can search for biographical information online elsewhere or even check for it on the site. See if the author provides their email address, mailing address and phone number.

3. Publishing Body - Who pubished the site?

Check for the server computer from which the site is issued. The server should make sense, varify if it is a well known server. Look for it in the url.

www.helixcharter.net

4. Currency - When was the sited created and last updated?

Verify the copywrite date is fairly current and being maintained. Is the information sufficiently current for the topic?

5. Content and Scope - How much information and what kind of information does this site cover?

How indepth is the informatio? Does it match your expectations? Does it focus on your specific research? Is it written well, with no grammatical errors?

6. Audience - Who is the author writing the site for?

Commerical sites are often attempting to sell their audience, educational sites attempt to instruct, and nonprofits are looking for support for their causes. Is the site written for adults or children, doctors or the general public. You can determine the audience often by reading the first few paragraphs.

7. Bias - How objective is the author and what point is he or she trying to make?

Rarely is any writing nuetral, every author is trying to prove their stance. Hopefully the author tries to present both sides and research to support their vantage point.

8. Documentation - Does the site have sources linked to it and what are they and are they current?

Investigating the sources helps you understand whether the work is founded upon previous research or not. A diligent search may uncover whether the sources are up to date and scholarly or even offered at all. Some sites list resources that may not exist to gain your support falsely.

9. Links to and From - What kinds of sites are listed as resources and which sites have links to it?

If well respected sites are linked to it and are linked within the site that is a clue to its value. Also are the links working and the pages within the site complete?

 

The Case of Missing Sherlock Holmes Novel

A Study in Evaluating Web Site

You have just been trained as an amateur web site sleuth. You were quitely and productively working on art homework when you heard a book drop and footsteps running out the door. You drop your pencil and run to find your father's prized Sherlock Holmes Library collection disturbed. Unfortunately your father is on vacation in the wilds of Africa and is unable to be reached. One book has been stolen and you have no idea which one or why. Fortunately the thief has left you a clue to start you on the way to finding out which book was stolen, where it is hidden and why. Search the website provided below and complete the worksheet attached to find out who, where and why.

Evaluation of Web Sites Worksheet

Clue 1- You pick up a note dropped on the floor and there was an address of a site that listed all of Arthur Conan Doyle's Stories. You can use this list to help you narrow down your search.

http://www.sherlockian.net/canon/index.html

These sites must be done in order and choose the best answer from the best site.

War and Remembrance - List one of the dates found in paragraph 3.

The Mark Twain House - List one of the dates found in paragraph 1.

Clue 2- List the correct date:

 

 

 

Copyright ©2003 by Christine Colera.